Coney Pizza 1
Coney Pizza 2
Coney Pizza 3
Coney Pizza 4
Coney Pizza 5
Coney Pizza 6

Welcome to Coney Pizza

About Coney Pizza

There's a little corner in Lonaconing, Maryland, that’s been generating quite a bit of buzz lately—Coney Pizza. Tucked away at 50 Main St, this charming spot has quickly carved a niche for itself among locals and visitors alike. It's not just your typical pizza joint; Coney Pizza brings something unique to the table, quite literally.

Every pizza aficionado will appreciate the creativity that goes into the menu here. Sure, the classics are available, like the trusty Margherita or the ever-popular Pepperoni. However, it's the specialty pizzas where the magic really happens. The "Crabby Pie," for instance, topped with succulent Maryland blue crab, takes a local staple to tasty new heights. The adventurous "Spicy Honey Drizzler," daring diners with a mix of spicy sausage, red pepper flakes, and a tantalizing honey drizzle, has earned quite a few gold stars from spicy food lovers.

Coney Pizza isn't just about their pizzas, though. Starters like fried calamari and garlic knots are hard to resist, and they sit perfectly alongside a refreshingly bubbly soda or a crisp, locally brewed beer on tap. The ambiance feels just right, balancing that homey comfort you want from a pizzeria with a modern twist that keeps it interesting.

As for how the town feels about Coney Pizza, just eavesdrop on the chatter both in-person and online. Reviews have been generous, praising not just the quality of the food but the friendly, family-like vibe celebrated in every visit. It seems that word-of-mouth carries some significant clout around here, and Coney Pizza appears to have earned its stripes quickly.

Coney Pizza’s convenient location on the main drag makes it easy to find. It’s the kind of place where patrons might be tempted to gasp, "How did I not know about this sooner?" Walking through its doors feels like being greeted by an old friend whose culinary skills just happen to be on point every single time.

So for those in and around Lonaconing needing a pizza fix—or those just passing through with a craving for something both good and a bit outside the ordinary—Coney Pizza stands ready and waiting. And trust, no one leaves this charming pizzeria without the satisfied smile of someone who’s just discovered a bit of a hidden gem.

Features & Amenities

Service Options

  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Popular For

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining

Offerings

  • Comfort food
  • Quick bite
  • Small plates

Dining Options

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Dessert

Amenities

  • Restroom

Atmosphere

  • Casual

Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards

Children

  • Good for kids
  • Kids' menu

Parking

  • Free parking lot
  • Free street parking

Planning

  • Accepts reservations

Reviews

Average Rating
3.8/5
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Ashley M
Wings are the largest and crispiest in the area. So delicious. The Jack Daniele’s sauce is sweet with a little bit of kick. Best wings I have had in a long time.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Peppermint Patti
We got wings and celery/blue cheese. We picked it up and everything was hot and tasted great! The young lady that waited on us was very nice. They only take cash and checks, no cards. Definitely recommend.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Brandy Twigg
I got the large pizza and wings deal! I got blue cheese and mild on my wings and they were amazing!! My pizza had mushrooms and pepperoni. Really good pizza! Everything was so good! I also got their fried dough balls with icing and those are so delicious! Super friendly staff!! Just wish they weren't so busy all the time for delivery but I understand! Five stars in my book!
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — Tracy Winebrenner
We got two pizzas delivered up to the pool over the weekend. My husband who is very picky said the crust was perfect, and it was probably the best pizza he’s had in a long while. I grew up on coney pizza, he unfortunately didn’t. Hats off to you all he’s very hard to please. He said we will be back for sure 😂

Give Us Your Honest Feedback

Opening Hours

  • Monday: 10 AM–11 PM
  • Tuesday: 10 AM–11 PM
  • Wednesday: 10 AM–11 PM
  • Thursday: 10 AM–11 PM
  • Friday: 10 AM–12 AM
  • Saturday: 10 AM–12 AM
  • Sunday: 10 AM–11 PM